The First Rule of Writing Is Writer’s Block Does Not Exist

Image: an open laptop with a blank white screen sits on a table with notepads, a mobile phone and potted succulents with a view of a sunlit and greenery-filled patio in the background.

Today’s post is by SaaS copywriter Alexander Lewis (@alexander-j-lewis).


On New Year’s Eve 2022, I stood in my backyard surrounded by friends, finishing the last drags of a cigar. In the dark, we took turns sharing our hopes for 2023. I knew my goal. It was clear and succinct in my mind because I’d been noodling on it for weeks. But as others shared one by one in a circle, I second-guessed my goal. All the resolutions before mine were about family and health and finding balance in the new year. Would my resolution about business and money seem crass? Could I jinx myself? Too late. It was my turn. I stuck with my original answer, “I’m going to double my writing business in 2023.”

Crass or not, my goal wasn’t outlandish. In past years I’ve grown the business by almost 90%. But 2023 wasn’t like the previous seven years. Not even close. I didn’t merely undershoot a lofty target. 2023 was the first time my writing earnings were lower than the year before. Revenue tipped backward. Jinx!

A lot happened last year. It was a difficult and strange time to be a working writer. There were fears around AI. My sector, tech, suffered an effective bear market which resulted in a slowdown in hiring. Interest rates rose and marketing budgets were reduced. And exactly midway through the year, I endured the biggest health crisis of my life.

There’s just one problem: None of these factors were within my control. I’d be lying or lazy (or both) to say that last year’s under-performance was purely circumstantial. I made a mistake and effectively tied my hands behind my back. What do I mean? In 2023, for the first time in my writing career, I stopped writing for myself.

The best way to write for others is to write for yourself

Freelance writers have the ultimate edge when it comes to sourcing new leads. Every time you publish an article or new social post, no matter the subject, you’re marketing your services as a writer for hire. Words are your product. Writers often meet their first client by accident. You publish a blog, someone reads it, loves it, and asks you to write something similar for them—for a fee.

Call it the “flywheel” of freelance writing. Call it, “building your writer brand.” It all translates the same: The best way to write for others is to write for yourself.

I began freelancing full-time in 2016. From then until 2022, no matter how busy I was with client work, I always made time to write for myself. Blogging. Social media writing. Guest posting. Half the fun of growing a freelance business was writing the stories that no one asked for, but that I wanted to tell.

It worked. The more I wrote for myself, the more others wanted to work with me. The more publications I wrote for, the easier it became to pitch the next one. All I had to do was keep writing…

That’s where the problem originated. If the best way to write for others is to write for yourself, then the opposite is also true. The surest way to slow your writing career is to stop writing for yourself. And damn it! that’s exactly what I did.

The first rule

The first rule of freelance writing is that writer’s block does not exist.

To write consistently for yourself, you must believe as a fundamental principle that writing is a matter of discipline. As soon as you believe (even partially) that writer’s block exists, you set yourself up for failure. Writer’s block is an excuse, based on fear, that a writer stores in their back pocket. The excuse gives you permission to quit as soon as writing gets hard.

Writing was hard for me in 2023. I think the difficulty started because I was bummed about AI. For me, writing is pleasurable because it is difficult. Now, something that was difficult in nature was made simpler by a machine. It stole some of the fun of writing. So, I stopped writing for a week. One week became a month. One month became a few. And by the end of 2023, I had almost no new personal writing to show for a full year.

I believe writer’s block starts in fear. Most often, I think it’s the fear of perfection. Writers put too much pressure on their first draft. They fear the flashing cursor and never type the first sentence. This has seldom been a problem for me.

Writer’s block arrived for me in the form of a different fear. It was the fear that my work was made meaningless by a machine. It’s silly when I say it out loud. Finding meaning in one’s work is a matter of choice. Besides, if the process of writing is what makes it meaningful to me, then I can continue to write however I please.

Still, I never rationalized my way out of fear. The result was I ignored the blank page. The worst part is that I missed it. 

It takes guts to write

The best writing is scary to publish because it is vulnerable. It takes guts to share your stories and ideas. People can misunderstand. They can object. Clicking publish makes you an easy target to be picked on. Maybe you’re wrong and are called out publicly. Or maybe you’re right and called out anyway.

Every writer must decide for themselves if the vulnerability is worth it. For me, there’s almost no activity I love more than clicking publish on an idea I’ve wrestled with in silence for hours.

A few weeks ago, my wife Sarabeth and I took a walk around Lady Bird Lake in Austin. We let our aussiedoodle Oliver off-leash to sniff around for lost tennis balls at Zilker Park. That’s when I had a new idea for setting resolutions. “What if we set resolutions for one another, based on what we think would make the other happiest?”

We each mulled over possible resolutions in silence for several minutes. I leashed Oliver again as we reached the end of the park. We continued down the sidewalk and then the dirt path. I shared some resolutions for Sarabeth and she gave me a few in turn. One of them was clearly the most important.

“I think you’re happiest when you’re writing,” Sarabeth said.

I still have lofty financial goals for my writing business this year. But my primary goal for 2024 will not be a revenue target, but a writerly one. I am returning to the foundations of a good writing life. My resolution is to rediscover my writing routines and start publishing my work once again.

If the past eight years of freelancing have taught me anything, it’s this: When I write for myself, the revenue takes care of itself.

Share on:
Subscribe
Notify of
guest

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

15 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Ken Hughes

A great analysis — life changes, but writing can still be writing.

I don’t think writer’s block exists as a single thing. Being exhausted can be real; having a project that needs fixing can happen; sometimes it really does come down to putting in more work. Discipline can always help. But saying “writer’s block” is a thing in itself would be saying we have a problem we refuse to find the right answer for.

Alexander Lewis

I love this line of thinking. Essentially, “writer’s block” is too vague. It’s too amorphous to be useful to the writer.

Dina Santorelli

*For me, writing is pleasurable because it is difficult.*

And here I thought I was the only one who felt that way. 🙂

Excellent post. I’m so glad you rediscovered the joy.

Alexander Lewis

Glad that resonated with you. Thank you!

Donn King

I had prided myself on never experiencing writer’s block. After all, telling my newspaper editor that I just couldn’t find my muse would only elicit laughter. The deadline was still the deadline. Plus, I had worked out routines that would get the juices flowing no matter what. I made part or, at times, all of my living with writing for over 40 years, and while sometimes the words flowed like a new faucet and other times they came like auguring out a stopped-up sink, they always came.

Until they didn’t.

Caring for my disabled daughter left me exhausted, and eventually the words stopped coming. It didn’t feel like Writer’s Block. The experience had nothing to do with faucets or stubborn drains. It felt like the well had simply gone dry. For 10 years, I tried to write, and there was nothing there. I wrestled with depression, driven by the exhaustion, and I thought, “That ship has sailed.” A lot of things end as you get older. I figured that was just one of them for me.

I suggested a book idea to an author friend, and he said I should write it myself. I told him I didn’t know if anything was there for me, but I gave it a try since I had a copy of Scrivener that I had already paid for. The “sunk cost fallacy” worked for me. It turns out the well wasn’t dry. It just needed a new spigot.

I had told myself I wasn’t writing because I was depressed. It turns out I was depressed because I wasn’t writing. My wife told me the same thing Alexander’s wife told him: “You’re happiest when you’re writing.”

My book came out in October, the first in a planned trilogy, and the second book will come out in March.

I’m not suggesting that all a depressed person has to do is write. But I think maybe a lot of depression that isn’t clinical may stem from denying something a given person considers essential to their identity. In honoring whatever that is, you’re most likely to give something valuable to the world. Kudos to Alexander, and I’m glad for the insight.

Alexander Lewis

Wow! Donn, thank you for sharing that story. Huge congrats on the book(s)! I’m glad to hear that you rediscovered your writing life. For some of us, writing has a profound impact on our mental health. I’ve certainly discovered that for myself. Welcome back to the writing game.

Leslie L. Nielsen

Thank you for this! By clicking publish, you cast a healthy vote for all of us writers.

Alexander Lewis

Thanks for your kind words, Leslie!

Donna

Great Scott man, you hit the nail on the head!

My favorite line: “Half the fun of growing a freelance business was writing the stories that no one asked for, but that I wanted to tell.” – Indeed! Here’s to writing your heart out. I believe your wife is correct.

Hope your health scare is resolved as well.

Alexander Lewis

Yes, fully recovered now. Thank you!

I’m glad that line resonated. It’s been true for me since I started the business in 2016.

THOMAS HAUCK

Hi Alexander – I loved your very thoughtful and insightful essay on writer’s block. Any type of creative endeavor relies on the self-motivation of the artist or creator. I suppose I must consider myself lucky because the question of writer’s block is, for me, a moot point. I’m a professional ghostwriter and editor, and if I don’t sit down at my desk and write books for my clients, my mortgage won’t get paid. The possibility of losing my house is a powerful motivating force!

Alexander Lewis

Hi Thomas, great points. We have a lot in common. I’m a ghostwriter as well. To clarify, I haven’t had any trouble writing for clients. Deadlines and paychecks are highly motivating indeed! I was talking in this piece about making time to write for myself (which is how I market my services).

Thanks for reading and good luck with all your clients!

helen renell

I have been reading quite a bit of articles and books lately suggesting that writers should primarily write for themselves. No joy in slogging through what is not you!

I also loved that you shared your thoughts on AI.

Encouraging post.

Alexander Lewis

Thanks for reading, Helen! Agreed. I love writing for clients, but I’ve missed writing articles for myself. It’s a meaningful hobby. It’s also how I think.

AI has been a weird subject for many writers, including myself. I’m still sorting through all my thoughts on it. Glad you enjoyed the article!

Rachel Neumeier

Writer’s block does exist. The most pernicious form is clinical depression. Mistaking clinical depression for a lack of discipline is not remotely helpful to people experiencing this form of writer’s block, as vividly described, for example, by Mary Robinette Kowal in her blog post on this topic.